penélope plaza

My research interests are the the intersections between the politics of space and the politics of culture; modernity, architecture and urban space and the interfaces between space, bureaucratic power and culture with a particular interest in urban artivism and petrocultures.


Having spent my doctoral years immersed in understanding how petro-cultures and petro-politics shaped the city from the top down, I am now interested in how this is contested by creative practice from the ground. I am exploring cultural forms of critique and creative resistance to the power of the Petrostate and the oil industry on the instrumentalisation of public art and the resulting inequalities of access to public space, sustainable mobility, and culture more broadly.


I am a member of the Petrocultures Research Group and the After Oil 3 collective.

Design-Research Workshops

DRIVOSAUR

Penelope Plaza

Oliver Froome-Lewis


Re-Act by Design:

DESIGNING THE MEANTIME

International Design Workshop

Faculty of Design Sciences

University of Antwerp


14-18 February, 2022

"When they woke up, the ring road was still there." 

paraphrasing Augusto Monterroso's The Dinosaur, 1959


From above, we see a road, in a ring, a pulsating drivosaur laid out in the-places-that-avoid-and-separate-more-important-places. From the ground, we see individual vehicles, two-ton monsters carrying humans and cargoes: Herring from Stockholm, Haggis from Aberdeen, Marcolini Chocolates, Cheese from the Balearic Islands. Modest use of brains: steering, braking, choosing another lane, or another track, fingers tapping to music on the steering wheel. We see the dusty bustle of trucks, tractors, and bulldozers. At night the drivosaur becomes a snake of colour and light, passing without beginning or end. When this drivosaur goes underground, which it will, perhaps with a fumeless electric whirr, it will still be there. Meanwhile, we imagine.


This workshop looked ahead to the ghost vehicles of the ring-road. We collaborated with students to collectively imagine and construct drivosaurs that were be drawn, modelled and constructed as 1:1 mobile inflatable urban interventions in Luchtbal. Tissue and paper models first, then testing with a hairdryer, then filming the spectral interventions as traffic and people go by, , making and running with our ghosts. We revealed the ghostly DRIVOSAURS!


https://www.uantwerpen.be/en/projects/international-design-workshops/previously/designing-the-meantime-2022/workshops/



URBAN COME-ON’S

Penelope Plaza

Oliver Froome-Lewis

[Erasmus Staff Exchange]


Re-Act by Design:

COMMONS

International Design Workshop

Faculty of Design Sciences

University of Antwerp


10-14 February, 2020

Creating a new ‘field’ between neighbourhoods presented an un-common opportunity to nurture a stimulating social infrastructure for creative leisure. The act of commoning requires new modes of receiving, rewarding and extending existing patterns of living to succeed. We see this un-common ground as an Active Territory that can catalyse meaningful, yet subtle, connections through culture understood as a collective social being.


Our workshop engaged in propositional map-making, enabling students to create opportunities for micro-scale, pre-figurative, urban interventions to unlock new modes of urban commons for the community of Luchtbal. Propositional maps are maps with behavioural intent to produce a new, free flowing, territory that can be travelled in the imagination, in reality, or in both concurrently. Such forms of map propose new co-dependencies and dialogues between the imagination, expectations and experience.

Plunging into creative walking, mapping and map-making processes, converting the unconventional data revealed into a propositional-map-scape and proposing sites for micro interventions, we created a Graphic-Manifesto for Commoning. Working together we revealed opportunities for re-thinking cultural milieus and sharing life’s micro-pleasures.


https://www.uantwerpen.be/images/online/facow/idw2020/2-3/

Podcasts

click on image for link to podcast

VOLATILE TRAJECTORIES

2022

We are all imperiled by the climate emergency, but some of us are clearly more threatened than others. Human and nonhuman animals and entire ecosystems are under duress. It’s hard to know exactly where to place the emphasis in sketching the contours of an ongoing struggle for revolutions in energy use that could prevent the devastation of runaway global heating, but acknowledging that the impact is extremely uneven might be the most imperative.


Because there’s an urgent need for us to reject the reigning “energy regime” of fossil fuel extraction, a collective of authors and academics who collaborate under the name After Oil (https://afteroil.ca/) recently got together to imagine pathways out of our current impasse, to develop methods of resolving the sense of “stuckness” that defines our current moment, and to think about climate action. The outcome of that meeting was this six-episode podcast series, funded by Future Energy Systems and the Canada First Research Excellence Fund.


In episode 4 you’ll hear from Emily Eaton, Eva-Lynn Jagoe, Scott Stoneman, Mark Simpson and Penélope Plaza about our relationships to the places we know and care about, and about our discrete approaches to breaking the spell of fossil capitalism, petroculture, oil — the dominant energy regime of our time.


The conversation focuses on not just a love of the land, but stubborn attachments to particular uses of the land. Ways of cultivating, caring for, and working the land that have complex histories and serious consequences. We talk about the language of maintenance, both in terms of the maintenance of infrastructure, and in the context of a larger push for a culture of care that sees us taking a backseat to the land’s understanding of itself.

click on image for link to podcast

NEW BOOKS NETWORK:

CRITICAL THEORY

2018

How do states use cultural policy?In Culture as Renewable Oil: How Territory, Bureaucratic 

Power and Culture Coalesce in the Venezuelan Petrostate (Routledge, 2018), Penelope Plaza, a lecturer in architecture at the University of Reading explores the case study of Venezuela to think through the relationship between states, territory, and culture. The book develops the idea of culture as a resource, showing the close relationship between oil and culture, and culture and oil, along with the history of the Venezuelan petrostate. Packed with detailed visual analysis, along with a rich theoretical framework covering urban development, bureaucracy, and power, the book will be essential reading for anyone concerned with the role of culture in the city.

Research Grants

NERC Discipline Hopping for Environmental Solutions: Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation research for Latin America and the Caribbean


University of Reading Latin America and the Caribbean Research Network R-LAC,

Co-Investigator


January – March 2022

Series of three interdisciplinary research workshops and a sandpit activity at the end. The aim of the workshops is to understand the context and different perspectives and use system thinking to find common interdisciplinary theories and gaps that can help improve interdisciplinary approaches. These workshops culminated in a full-day research sandpit on Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation research for Latin America and the Caribbean. We aimed to find common ground between different theoretical and methodological perspectives and to co-design new research questions that address regional environmental challenges from a biosocial perspective that can underpin a larger application for research funding.  


The British Council Digital Collaboration Fund


Creating a Digital [CCSen365]:

exploring ways to deliver a

multi-sensorial and inclusive

experience of Caracas

architectural heritage via mobile

phone


March – August 2021

Dr Penelope Plaza and the Venezuelan not-for-profit CollectiVoX were awarded a grant from The British Council Digital Collaboration Fund.


The project Creating a Digital [CCSen365] was awarded a Research and Development small grant of £18,000.00 to explore ways to deliver a multi-sensorial and inclusive experience of Caracas architectural heritage via mobile phone.


The selection process was highly competitive; over 950 grant applications were received from across the globe.




Publications

2021

Rare Seeds: How Venezuelan Artists are Breaking the Spell of Oil

Energy Humanities



Venezuela has a long and complicated relationship with oil marked by cycles of hope and despair. Penélope Plaza of the University of Reading explores how three Venezuelan artists are working to break the spell of oil and help set the country on a new path.



2020


Tracing the elusive urban imprints of Paidia and Ludus

(self-published)

UROP Project , School of Architecture, University of Reading. 



 This UROP project is part of a longer-term practice-led research project that aims to investigate theories and methods for urban commoning through small ludic interventions and playable spaces. It will explore their potential for enabling new forms of commons in the city by temporarily transforming urban spaces into playable-spaces for intergenerational socialisation in the 21st century.


Drawing on my urban artivism in Caracas (Venezuela) as co-founder of CollectiVoX and active member of the playful protest collective Ser Urbano, this UROP placement carried out a historiographical survey of traditional and contemporary forms of ‘analogue’ play that can bridge cultures, generations and abilities.

 

The UROP student helped produce an illustrated catalogue of play, play-things and play-spaces drawing on Caillois categories of Paidia and Ludus.


BOOK LINK

2019


The Politics of Culture in the Chávez Era

BLAR Book Series, Wiley-Blackwell

This volume maps the trends in cultural policies and political cultures that accompanied Chávez’s four presidential terms (1999- 2013) in twenty-first century Venezuela. Within this overview, it develops original close readings of varied cultural activities, including political protest, urban culture, and grassroots heritage projects, alongside conventional aesthetic manifestations such as film and literature.

2019


The Rhetoric of Oil in the Twenty-First Century

Routledge

Chapter 8: Untangling the Myth of "Culture as Renewable Oil": A Barthesian Exploration of PDVSA La Estancia’s Visual Campaign Transformamos el petróleo en un recurso removable para ti.


This book examines mass communication and civic participation in the age of oil, analysing the rhetorical and discursive ways that governments and corporations shape public opinion and public policy and activists attempt to reframe public debates to resist corporate framing.

2018


Culture as Renewable Oil

Routledge

The book unpacks the links between oil energy, state power, urban space and culture, by looking at the Petro-Socialist Venezuelan oil state to examine how oil is a cultural resource, in addition to a natural resource, implying therefore that struggles over culture implicate oil, and struggles over oil implicate culture. 


  • Shortlisted for the Royal Geography Society's Political Geography Research Group Book Award 2018-2020
  • Awarded Special Commendation 



2011

From Bentham to Le Corbusier, Vigilance and Discipline in Modern Latin American Social Housing. The Pedregulho Housing Complex, Río de Janeiro, Brasil (1947-1958)

Plaza, Penélope (2011) From Bentham to Le Corbusier, Vigilance and Discipline in Modern Latin American Social Housing. The Pedregulho Housing Complex, Río de Janeiro, Brasil (1947-1958), Atenea, Nº 504, II Semestre, Universidad de Concepción, Chile, pp. 111-130. (Text in Spanish)

http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=32821477007


Photo: Conjunto Residencial Prefeito Mendes de Moraes (Pedregulho), Marcel Gautherot, 1947.


2010


Armed Mother and Child: The Depiction of the New Woman in Revolutionary Nicaragua Murals.

Plaza, Penélope (2010) Armed Mother and Child: The Depiction of the New Woman in Revolutionary Nicaragua Murals. Apuntes, Vol. 23, N° 1. Bogotá: Instituto Carlos Arbeláez, Pontificia Universidad Javeriana, ENE-JUN 2010. (Text in Spanish)


Photo: Mural Casa Nacional AMNLAE, Brigada Rodrigo Peñalba, 1983. Destroyed in 1987.





2008


Building a Nation under the New National Ideal. Public Works, Representation and Ideology during Perez Jimenez Dictatorship, 1952-1958

Plaza, Penélope (2008) Building a Nation under the New National Ideal. Public Works, Representation and Ideology during Perez Jimenez Dictatorship, 1952-1958. Semana Internacional de Investigación Facultad de Arquitectura y Urbanismo. Ponencias in Extenso (CD). Caracas: FAU-UCV, October 2008, pp. [HP-12] 1- [HP-12] 24. (Text in Spanish)


Use this space to add more information about the work you’ve shown on the side. This layout is perfect for behind the scenes studio photography. 


Photo: Parade at the Paseo de los Próceres, Caracas, during the Semana de la Patria. Photo: Archivo Fotografía Urbana


dissertations

PhD Dissertation, 2017

“Oil that Harvests Culture”: State, Oil and Culture in Petrosocialism (Venezuela, 2007-2013)

PhD in Cultural Policy and Management

Centre for Culture and Creative Industries

Department of Sociology,

City, University of London


The thesis develops a story about Venezuela as an oil state and the way it deploys its policies to instrumentalise culture and urban space. It examines the way the Petrostate is imagined in speeches, how it manifests physically in space and how it is discursively constructed in adverts. By engaging with the works of Lefebvre, Jessop and Yúdice the thesis set out to challenge the disciplinary compartmentalisation of the analysis of the material and cultural effects of oil to demonstrate that within the extractive logic of the Petrostate and the oil industry, territory, oil, and culture become indivisible. Mainly, it explores how the material and immaterial flows of oil traverse space, bureaucratic power, and culture. Building on Yúdice’s expediency of culture as a resource it proposes the notion of culture-as-mineral-deposit, in which culture is inextricable from land, akin to ‘renewable oil’ and tightly controlled by the Petrostate.


MPhil Dissertation, 2005

Building a Nation under El Nuevo Ideal Nacional. Public Works, Ideology and Representation during the Pérez Jiménez dictatorship, 1952-1958

MPhil in Latin American Studies

Centre for Latin American Studies

University of Cambridge


During the 1950s, Venezuela became the country with the most ambitious projects of modern architecture and urban planning in Latin America. This thesis explores the policies derived from “El Nuevo Ideal Nacional”, the dictatorship’s ideological framework built on the notion of Democratic Ceasarism developed by Laureano Vallenilla Lanz. I examine in particular the ambitions to modernise the country through the “transformation of the physical environment” and the betterment of Venezuelans through the investment of the oil rent windfall in massive projects of infrastructure. I analyse emblematic examples of public works built by the regime in relation to the cultural and socio-economic context.


Photo: Bloques 5, 6 y 7, re-urbanización El Silencio. Caracas, 1945, Ricardo De Sola ©Archivo Fotografía Urbana.

conferences

International Design Workshop 2020: Pecha Kucha Presentations

Oliver Froome-Lewis & Penelope Plaza

11-13 February 2020, Church Luchtbal, Antwerp.


Re-Act by Design. Organised by the Faculty of Design Sciences, University of Antwerp.


London/Caracas: Propositional Map-Making and Prefigurative Urban Interventions

Petrocultures 2016: The Offshore


Memorial University of Newfoundland, Canada. 31 August-3 September 2016


Utopian Visions of Petrosocialism in Urban Space



My current research explores the relationship between the petrostate, the state-owned oil company PDVSA, and urban space in Venezuela, focusing primarily on the spatialization of the power of oil through the work of PDVSA La Estancia -the social and cultural arm of the state owned oil company- and the construction of imaginaries of petrosocialism in the city of Caracas. Hugo Chavez claimed he was a building a socialism different to the one that Marx had envisioned, his socialism was the socialism of the 21st century, a Bolivarian socialism, a socialism fed/supported by the oil rent, in sum, petrosocialism. This raises the question, what does a petrosocialist city look like? To answer this question, this paper looks in particular at the visual campaign launched by PDVSA La Estancia in 2013, titled “We transform oil into a renewable resource for you” through the semiotic lens of Roland Barthes’ myths and George Yudice’s Expediency of Culture. I argue that the adverts provide a fabricated imaginary of urban life under petrosocialism, a complex vision of a particular lived geography that attempts to integrate high culture and aesthetics in urban spaces that will be governed by the legal instruments of the Socialist/Communal State.

Exit Velocity: The Cultural Capital Exchange, 2016

University of West London, 24 June.


Sowing Oil, Harvesting Culture: the Law of Hydrocarbons as Implicit Cultural Policy


In 2007 Hugo Chavez affirmed he was a building a socialism different to what Karl Marx had envisioned, a socialism of the 21st century leveraged by the oil rent, in other words, Petrosocialism. PDVSA, the state-owned oil company effectively became the “engine of revolutionary change” (Maass 2009, pp.202, 215). That same year, PDVSA La Estancia, the social and cultural arm of PDVSA, embarked on an ambitious program of public art restoration and urban regeneration under the Sowing Oil Plan, guided the Law of Hydrocarbons. My current research explores the construction of discursive territories for cultural representations of petrosocialism in the city of Caracas through the work of PDVSA La Estancia. This paper asks: what notion of culture is mobilized under petrosocialism? Drawing on Tony Bennet’s conceptualisation of culture as a field of government, Yudice’s notion of culture as a resource, and Jeremy Ahearne’s categorisation of implicit cultural policy, this paper will explore the institutional circumstances that allowed for the interpretation and implementation of the Law of Hydrocarbons as an implicit cultural policy, superseding the authority of existing institutions of cultural and urban governance.

SLAS Annual Conference 2015

Aberdeen, 17-18 April


The Spatialisation of the Power of Oil: PDVSA as place entrepreneur in the regeneration of Sabana Grande Boulevard


In 2007, as part of the celebration of “La semana de Caracas”, PDVSA La Estancia (the social and cultural arm of PDVSA, the Venezuelan state-owned oil and natural gas Company) launched in partnership with the Libertador Municipality a National Competition of Ideas to gather architecture and urban design proposals for the integral rehabilitation of the Sabana Grande Boulevard and surrounding areas, that at the time were in disrepair and neglect. PDVSA La Estancia took control of the large scale infrastructure investment to transform Sabana Grande Boulevard’s urban landscape space in which imaginaries of oil are embedded throughout the space by way of the oil company’s branding, visual campaigns, urban furniture and choice of public art. Drawing on Lefebvre, and following Saskia Sassen’s assertion that city space is the ideal site for the spatialisation of power projects, this paper will explore the construction and mobilisation of culture in public space through the works of urban regeneration promoted and executed by PDVSA La Estancia, in which oil is integrated to the repertoire of cultural symbols of the Bolivarian Petro-state, and as a symbol of the power of PDVSA over other institutional instances of the Venezuelan state.

Congreso Internacional Ciudades Latinoamericanas: La utopía intelectual en una geografía inestable, 2009


Facultad de Filosofía y Literatura, Universidad de Buenos Aires, 12 November.


Del rancho a la modernidad: panopticismo y “domesticación” en la vivienda social moderna en Brasil y Venezuela, el caso de Pedregulho y El Silencio, 1940-1950. (From Slum to Modernity: Panoptism in Modern Social Housing in Brazil and Venezuela)


Esta ponencia es parte de una investigación recién iniciada sobre las transformaciones que ha sufrido la ciudad en la posmodernidad, manifiestas como síntomas espaciales y arquitectónicos de lo que Zygmunt Bauman denomina “vida líquida”, ese modo de vida de este mundo contemporáneo “líquido” lleno de incertidumbres como consecuencia del fracaso del proyecto modernista. Este trabajo en específico se enfoca en los primeros grandes proyectos modernos de vivienda social en Latinoamérica, impulsados por trasformaciones urbanas modernizadoras e higienistas, explorando espacialmente la relación entre las instituciones de poder que encargaron los proyectos, la arquitectura y sus habitantes. Como casos estudio se escogieron Los Bloques de El Silencio (1941-1945) en Caracas y el Complejo Habitacional Pedregulho (1946- 1952) en Rio de Janeiro. La arquitectura se concibió como el vehículo para la “transformación social”, para la transición de la miseria a la pureza, de la enfermedad a la salud, de la ignorancia a la educación, del rancho a la modernidad. La relación entre la arquitectura, sus ocupantes y la autoridad se plantea en este trabajo como “panóptica”. Ambos proyectos no son panópticos en el sentido arquitectónico, sin embargo la manera como fueron gestionados por las autoridades califica como lo que Foucault denominó como “panopticismo”. A pesar poseer claras diferencias arquitectónicas y estilísticas, tienen en común un factor clave: ser símbolos de una promesa de progreso, de la expectativa de que la arquitectura sería un vehículo de transformación social a través de la “domesticación” de aquellos escogidos para ocupar las nuevas viviendas.

Semana Internacional de Investigación 2008

Facultad de Arquitectura y Urbanismo Universidad Central de Venezuela, 2 October.


Building a Nation Under the New National Ideal. Public Works, Representation and Ideology during Perez Jimenez Dictatorship 1952-1958


(In Spanish)

El ascenso al poder de Marcos Pérez Jiménez en 1952 coincidió con un clima económico favorable, cuyo motor fue la expansión de la industria petrolera. El incremento en los ingresos petroleros permitió al régimen financiar un programa ambicioso de industrialización y modernización. Los logros de dicha administración se enmarcaron dentro de la ideología del Nuevo Ideal Nacional. Concebido por Pérez Jiménez y empleado por él como propaganda, el Nuevo Ideal Nacional se presentó como un concepto ideológico venezolano muy singular, que se sustentaba en la tradición histórica, la abundancia de recursos naturales y la situación geográfica favorable del país. El propósito principal del ideal era “la transformación del medio físico y el mejoramiento de las condiciones morales, intelectuales y materiales de los venezolanos”. Esta ponencia tiene como objetivo explorar las políticas derivadas de la ideología denominada Nuevo Ideal Nacional. En particular, examinaré las ambiciones de esta ideología de modernizar el país por medio de “la transformación del entorno físico” y el mejoramiento de todos los venezolanos. Pérez Jiménez se propuso concretar el desarrollo material y embellecimiento de Venezuela, para lo cual se abocó a construir grandiosas obras públicas como evidencia tangible del progreso del país. Analizaré varios ejemplos emblemáticos de obras públicas construidas por el régimen y los colocaré en contexto con las circunstancias socioeconómicas de la época. Asimismo, esgrimiré el argumento de que la mejora de los venezolanos sólo benefició a unos pocos privilegiados, a pesar de que en efecto se había logrado la transformación física el país.


Durante la década de 1950, Venezuela se convirtió en el país latinoamericano con mayores logros arquitectónicos, tanto en calidad como en cantidad. Caracas fue la ciudad seleccionada para expresar el fino gusto oficial con obras de arquitectura y embellecimiento urbano. La arquitectura sirvió entonces como instrumento iconográfico para plasmar la ideología del Estado.